Escape 29: Can psychology do it?


Escape 29: Can psychology do it?

My, my, this is a tough question for all of those people who would want science to provide prescriptions for future behaviour or for the amelioration of the human condition.  Can psychology do it?  Becker writes:

We can talk for a century about what causes human aggression; we can try to find the springs in animal instincts, or we can try to find them in bottled-up hatreds due to frustration or in some kind of miscarried experiences of early years, of poor child handling and training.  All these would be true, but still trivial because men kill out of joy, in the experience of expansive transcendence over evil. If men kill out of heroic joy, what direction do we program for improvements in human nature?  What are we going to improve if men work evil out of the impulse to righteousness and goodness?

if men are aggressive in order to expand life, if aggression in the service of life is man’s highest creative act?

Doesn’t look too promising does it?  Not only that, Becker reflects on the idea that crazy, twisted people don’t do anywhere near as much damage to life as idealistic leaders.  Leaders, no matter how screwed up they are,  are still for people an ‘expression of the widespread urge to heroic transcendence.’ (p. 156)

Today we are living the grotesque spectacle of the poisoning of the earth by the nineteenth-century hero system of unrestrained material production.  This is perhaps the greatest and most pervasive evil to have emerged in all of history, and it may even eventually defeat all of mankind.  Still, there are no ‘twisted’ people whom we can hold responsible for this.

Well, I’m thinking there may be the odd ‘twisted’ bastard out there in the ranks of the world’s ‘leaders.’  I’m thinking Dick Cheney might qualify.  If nothing else he and people like him, including Stephen Harper, are prepared to sacrifice anything including the viability of the only home they have, the earth.  That’s twisted in my mind.  Freud admitted himself that ‘there is no dependable line between normal and abnormal in affairs of the human world.’ (p. 156) WFT.  So is there any hope for psychology, real psychology? I don’t really know.  Not sure exactly what hope would look like.  Becker was not convinced that the ‘psychical’ sciences could offer much in the way of advice to the human race.

Still, Becker notes, that Freud, no matter how cynical he got, always trusted psychoanalysis.  In the end he believed in it as anyone believes in their particular hero system. That’s probably true of a lot of psychologists.

Well, the simple answer to the question in the title of this blog is no.  How does psychology deal with problems of ‘cosmic heroism?’  So, now we come to the end of this Becker marathon.  Tomorrow, in my last post in this series, I see what Becker has to say again about The Science of Man.

4 thoughts on “Escape 29: Can psychology do it?

  1. Roger, scream and hurl insults at me if you wish. As I read your posts, the thought occurs to me that Becker is almost your guru or your “religious” leader. From what I understand of life, science cannot, and will not ever deal with the above problems. This is why we all need a genuine change of heart. Not everyone will accept this, but many do change their hearts and minds. It lies in the human choice of each individual and for those who have diseases of the mind, it’s interesting that many of them have very loving tender hearts when they are not triggered through past hurts and fears to lash out in anger etc. It would be wonderful if there was a pill that could help all of our problems. For those with diseases such as manic depression (which involves impatience and outrageous and angry outburst at times) lithium is a good solution in the proper dose, but for many others, there seems to be no effective treatment. My late husband was the kindest, most generous man when he was well, but when in a state of mania, he had to be arrested at times and forcibly committed to the psych ward against his will. He kicked up a fight against the nurses and doctors, but after he had his injection, he toned down and became normal after a few days. Just using this for an example. Did you hear about the mentally ill children and teens battering the nurses (in Burnaby)? This was on CBC news this evening. I need to shut down tonight.

    1. Marilyn, I never scream and hurl insults…:-) As far as Becker being my guru, I don’t think so. I like his work and style, but there are other scholars I find very important too for understanding our fears of life and death. I’m reading a French philosopher at the moment, Luc Ferry. I think his work is pretty awesome, as is Otto Rank’s. I gave up on guru’s a long time ago, when I was able to shed my fear of death (after many years of working on it). Obviously, I am a human and have to act, do things. I can get a bit obsessive about these things sometimes, but I make choices daily about what to do. I’m aware of my frailties and my strengths and live accordingly. I’ll write more about this later.
      BTW, I did hear about the Maples situation in Burnaby. Pretty nasty. They talk about 17 year olds as being children. Boy I didn’t think I was a child when I was 17. It’s a legal thing. The workers definitely need some protection. Obviously the patients are severely disturbed. This is a forensic facility, after all…but don’t get me started on psychiatry!

Please leave a comment. Click here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s